About Me

Saturday, June 6, 2009

Cries and Whispers

Ingmar Bergman has a way of making me despair with an intensity I can't even begin to verbalise. Yet I watch his movies, thriving in that very fear, pain, sadness and madness that his cameras capture so beautifully. Sometimes, I feel almost shameful that I watch his movies just to be disturbed by them. Yet, when I realise that his work moves so many people, I realise I am not the only mad person who revels in the misery and feels the futility of human existence and search for meaning in this mad, meaningless world.
Today, alone at home, I watched Cries and Whispers. I think it is about suffering, death, faith(and the lack of), love(and the lack of) and the human condition. It depicts this by portraying so beautifully, the relationship between three sisters, one of whom is in her deathbed of their childhood home, cared for by a maid named Anna. Her two sisters come to stay with her in her last days.
Agnes is the sister who is in her deathbed. She suffers intense physical pain and visible agony. The other two sisters, Karin and Maria, on the other hand, suffer silently. They live what is apparently a very normal life, but are infinitely unhappy, indifferent and cynical; having lost faith in god and the ability to love. Anna, the maid, is one person who still is capable of some love. Incidentally, she is also the only one who has some faith. Even the pastor's eyes at the funeral were filled with doubt.
How does Bergman portray misery the way he does. You wonder if he searches for it, pins it down, magnifies it and captures it in his camera? But in the end, he leaves you feeling like he really didn't have to "search" for misery. It is just there. EVERYWHERE.
At the end of the movie, Bergman shows Anna reading out of Agnes' diary after the two sisters and their husbands quite coldly, leave Anna home alone :
Wednesday 3 Sept. "The air is cold with the approaching autumn. It is mild and nice. My sisters Karin and Maria have come to see me. It is lovely to be together again like the old days. I am feeling much better too, like the old days. We even went for a short walk. It was such an event. Especially for me, who hadn't been out of doors for so long. Suddenly we all ran, laughing to the old swing. We sat in it - three good little sisters. Anna rocked us, slowly and gently. All my pain was gone. The people I am most fond of were with me. I heard them chatting. I felt the presence of their bodies and the warmth of their hands. I wanted the moment to stay and I thought: This really is happiness. I couldn't wish for anything better. Now, for a few minutes, I can experience consummation. And I feel so deeply grateful to life which gives me so much."
... And so the cries and whispers die away.
God, it makes me cry out with pain. Look at how subtly he brings out the irony of life! Do you see, the integral experience of the collective human body and mind - its consciousness, subconsciousness and everything else that is unknown, is what Bergman is trying to portray?

I watched the movie knowing what his movies can do to me. And he does exactly that. And worse. Each time. Then you admire the beauty of his art. In this case, the reds. The close ups. The misery only he can bring out. The silence. Minimal, yet powerful exchange of words. You get so immersed in the misery, it becomes yours. But that is exactly what you want and what it is about. That misery is everywhere. If misery is not there or at least not supposed to be there according to all logic, we will make it up. We revel in it. We make it worse. And in the end, you see that where misery is supposed to be, there are traces of happiness. It drives me crazy. Does it do the same to you?

8 comments:

dispassionate_observer said...

Notes from the movie subtitles. :)

The priest at the funeral. And his face is doubtful. Then he goes closer to Agnes' body and says:
If it be that you gathered our suffering in your poor body, and have borne it with you through death.. If it be that you meet god there, in that other land.. If it be that he turns his face towards you.. If it be that you will know the language of our lord.. If it be that you can speak to the Lord.. If it be so: pray for us. Agnes, dear child, listen to what I tell you now. Pray for us who are left on this dark and dirty earth.. beneath an empty and cruel sky. Lay your burden of suffering at the Lord's feet.. and ask him to pardon us. Ask him to set us free at last. from our anxiety. our weariness and our profound doubt. Ask him for a meaning to our lives. Agnes, you who have suffered so inconceivably and so long... you must be worthy to plead our case.

In the end, Bergman shows Anna reading out of Agnes' diary after the two sisters and their husbands leave Anna home alone :
Wednesday 3 Sept. "The air is cold with the approaching autumn. It is mild and nice. My sisters Karin and Maria have come to see me. It is lovely to be together again like the old days. I am feeling much better too, like the old days. We even went for a short walk. It was such an event. Especially for me, who hadn't been out of doors for so long. Suddenly we all ran, laughing to the old swing. We sat in it - three good little sisters. Anna rocked us, slowly and gently. All my pain was gone. The people I am most fond of were with me. I heard them chatting. I felt the presence of their bodies and the warmth of their hands. I wanted the moment to stay and I thought: This really is happiness. I couldn't wish for anything better. Now, for a few minutes, I can experience consummation. And I feel so deeply grateful to life which gives me so much."

... And so the cries and whispers die away.

Sandhya M said...

Such a coincidence that I watched my first Ingrid Bergman movie, the same day that you wrote this post.
His movie making is so different from anything I have seen.
Fanny and Alexander is the best movie about childhood and imagination that I have yet seen. I kind of get a feeling that this one was much more affirmative and positive than the ones you have mentioned.

Anonymous said...

scenes from a marriage was the most crapastic overhyped crap i saw

dispassionate_observer said...

@sandhya
:) i haven't seen that one. I'd love to see a "feel good" movie of his.

Sandhya M said...

Not exactly a feel good movie, but I am sure it wouldn't cause despair :)

dispassionate_observer said...

@anonymous
Not surprising. People that I forced the movie(scenes from a marriage) upon thought it was a mad movie about mad people who did mad things to themselves and to others!

But I didn't feel that way. It was not exactly what we would (want to) relate to but was absolutely believable. Very Very human. In fact it is frighteningly human. Why won't people like it? Why not?
You might ask, why would anyone do such a thing. It was not that he disliked her. That was just how it was. I love Liv Ullmann and the actor. Beautiful performances.

Gosh, sometimes it worries me that I like the madness!

Anonymous said...

Welcome to the Club.

dispassionate_observer said...

which club? Scenes from a marriage fanclub? ;)

 
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License